Ignite Creation Date:
2024-05-06 @ 3:07 PM
Last Modification Date:
2024-10-26 @ 1:43 PM
Study NCT ID:
NCT04529083
Status:
COMPLETED
Last Update Posted:
2024-07-03
First Post:
2020-08-24
Brief Title:
Mixed Reality Based System to Manage Phantom Pain Phantom Pain for Patients With Lower Limb Amputation
Sponsor:
Dallas VA Medical Center
Organization:
Dallas VA Medical Center
Study Overview
Official Title:
Feasibility and Functional Outcomes of a Novel Mixed Reality Based System to Manage Phantom Pain for Patients With Lower Limb Amputation
Status:
COMPLETED
Status Verified Date:
2024-03
Last Known Status:
Recruiting
Delayed Posting:
No
If Stopped, Why?:
Not Stopped
Has Expanded Access:
False
If Expanded Access, NCT#:
N/A
Has Expanded Access, NCT# Status:
N/A
Acronym:
MrMAPP
Brief Summary:
The primary goals of this pilot research project are a to design and develop the a mixed reality based system for managing phantom pain and b to evaluate the feasibility and preliminary functional outcomes of this system in a sample of patients with lower limb amputation Findings from this pilot study will serve as preliminary data to inform regarding a fully powered clinical trial to determine the effectiveness and practical implementation of these findings in real-world settings
Aim1 Design and develop a feasible mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain in patients with lower limb amputation qualifying for on-going mirror therapy
Hypothesis 1 The investigators hypothesize that the mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain will be feasible and well-received by a sample of patients with lower limb amputation needing mirror therapy
Aim2 Evaluate functional outcomes in a sample of lower limb amputees n10 using this mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain
Hypothesis 2 Using this system the investigators hypothesize that patients who participate in the mixed reality based system will show improvements in functional mobility based on performance evaluations and patient reported outcome measures PROs The investigators also hypothesize that this mixed reality based system will help to alleviate the phantom pain based on McGill Pain questionnaire and visual analog scale VAS
Aim1 Design and develop a feasible mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain in patients with lower limb amputation qualifying for on-going mirror therapy
Hypothesis 1 The investigators hypothesize that the mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain will be feasible and well-received by a sample of patients with lower limb amputation needing mirror therapy
Aim2 Evaluate functional outcomes in a sample of lower limb amputees n10 using this mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain
Hypothesis 2 Using this system the investigators hypothesize that patients who participate in the mixed reality based system will show improvements in functional mobility based on performance evaluations and patient reported outcome measures PROs The investigators also hypothesize that this mixed reality based system will help to alleviate the phantom pain based on McGill Pain questionnaire and visual analog scale VAS
Detailed Description:
The primary goals of this pilot research project are a to design and develop the a mixed reality based system for managing phantom pain and b to evaluate the feasibility and preliminary functional outcomes of this system in a sample of patients with lower limb amputation Findings from this pilot study will serve as preliminary data to inform regarding a fully powered clinical trial to determine the effectiveness and practical implementation of these findings in real-world settings
Aim1 Design and develop a feasible mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain in patients with lower limb amputation qualifying for on-going mirror therapy
Hypothesis 1 The investigators hypothesize that the mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain will be feasible and well received by a sample of patients with lower limb amputation needing mirror therapy
Aim2 Evaluate functional outcomes in a sample of lower limb amputees n10 using this mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain
Hypothesis 2 Using this system the investigators hypothesize that patients who participate in the mixed reality based system will show improvements in patient-reported outcome measures PROs The investigators also hypothesize that this mixed reality based system will help to alleviate the phantom pain based on Pain questionnaires and visual analog scale VAS
Patients 18 years of age and over with history of lower limb amputation and complaint of phantom limb pain Phantom limb pain is a condition experienced commonly by patients with major limb amputations
Men and women over the age of 18 with lower limb amputations greater than 3 months post surgery with phantom limb pain
-Exclusion criteria ---
Patients with lower limb amputations with open wounds or active infection in residual or contralateral limbs
Patients with history of seizures
Patients with visual self-reported or cognitive impairment assessed by the mini-mental state examination that interferes with ability to interact with participate in and adhere to a computerized rehabilitation system
Any patient with a cardiac event in the last 6 months
Any patient with an active medical issue to minimize risk of exacerbating their condition
Lives more than 60 miles away from the Dallas VA Medical Center
Any patient with the motion sickness induced by head mounted displays HMDs or immersive environment
Any patient experiencing the motion sickness induced by HMDs during the therapy session can also opt out of the study
In this exploratory pilot study a convenience sample of 10 patients will be recruited A sample of 10 subjects is adequate and consistent with other pilot behavioral intervention trials at the VA that have been completed and published
This is a pilot study is intended to yield preliminary data that will inform a fully powered trial to determine effectiveness of the novel Mixed Reality based system to manage phantom painA HIPAA waiver will be obtained to screen patients with lower limb amputation in the outpatient PMR clinics Eligible study candidates will be identified either during an initial visit as an outpatient during clinic visit with the physiatrist or review of prior visit with physiatrist The eligible pre-screened subjects will undergo a basic evaluation by rehabilitation physician After the evaluation the patient will be asked to participate in the study or sent invitation letter Once the eligible patient consents to enroll in the study with specific emphasis on safely performing the exercises independently at home The research team will provide the laptop camera and instruct the patient in its use at their home The patient will then use the system and perform the personalized home exercises every day for a 1 month period to evaluate sustainability of exercise behavior At the end of this period the system will be returned At initial clinic visit visit at week 1 and 1 month visit the patient will fill out pain questionnaires functional questionnaire without any identifiable PHI The images of the patients performing the exercises will be stored in the encrypted laptop and analyzed at UTD Also that the videos at UTD will be destroyed after 5 years but a copy will be kept at the Dallas VA
A HIPAA waiver will be obtained to screen patients with lower limb amputation in the outpatient clinics Eligible study candidates will be identified based on visit as an outpatient following hospital discharge the eligible pre-screened subjects will undergo a basic evaluation by rehabilitation physician After the evaluation the patient will be asked to participate in the study in person or by invitation letter Once the eligible patient consents to enroll in the study with specific emphasis on safely performing the exercises independently at home The research team will provide the laptop camera and instruct the patient in its use at their home The patient will then use the system and perform the personalized home exercises every day for a 1 month period to evaluate sustainability of exercise behavior At the end of this period the system will be returned by the patient at the final study visit or can be retrieved at subjects home at subjects request if unable to bring to final visit by research assistant Setting of the Study The subject will be participating in a therapy session of 15 minutes per day for a duration of 4 weeks Before starting a session the subject will be provided with oral instructions about the overall system and the purpose of study They will be asked to fill out a questionnaire asking the status of phantom pain phantom limb movement stress level etc After completing the questionnaire they will be allowed to move in virtual world to get acquainted Each session consists of three sub-sections where the subject is asked to play three different virtual games These virtual games are designed specifically for lower limb amputees Each game is targeting certain types of muscle movement We focused mainly on three types of movements 1 knee flexion and extension 2 ankle dorsiflexion and planar flexion and 3 tandem coordinated bilateral lower extremity movement Each game will be played only for 5 minutes After completing each sub-session the subject is asked to fill out similar questionnaire to record the effect
System Overview The system consists of one Microsoft Kinect camera Oculus Rift and a computer system with sufficient processing power Microsoft Kinect is used to scan the person and to create corresponding 3D model As shown in Figure 3 the 3D model for the phantom limb is obtained by mirroring the 3D model of the intact limb So the subject will be able to perceive both the limb in the virtual world The system provides a mixed reality based implementation of mirror therapy for managing phantom pain
Major features of this system include
Unconstrained movement As patient will be performing exercise in virtual environment the movement is not restricted by limited space as in case of traditional mirror box therapy where user can only move in the limits of box dimension Realistic illusion of phantom limb As the MrMAPP framework is using RGB-D camera to capture the movement of patients intact limb and mirror it to create the illusion of the phantom limb the illusion obtained is very realistic instead of using pre-built 3D model of a limb See Figure 4 Patient Encouragement Use of an immersive gaming environment motivates and keeps the patient engaging while performing exercise With the help of virtual reality various engaging game can be developed that helps to remove monotonousness in therapy sessions
Feedback with positive Reinforcement As each game is designed to encourage a patient to perform certain type of exercise the points earned in the game motivates the patient to perform better Adherence and compliance monitoring by recording and annotating the therapy sessions the coaching software will monitor parameters such as number of repetitions dates and times of exercises as well as correctness of performing the exercises This will serve as a real-time diary which is considered more reliable than self-report diaries that rely on patient recall of activityFunctional Outcome Measures a Visual Analog Scale for pain measurement VAS and b McGill Pain questionnaire c Additional questions that composite of the Mobility Activities of Daily LivingInstrumental Activities of Daily Living and Social Participation
At the end of the study the patient will have the option to leave feedback and suggestions for future use of this system
Descriptive methods will be used to characterize the sample population Pre-post t-tests or equivalent will be used to compare outcomes at one week and 1 month Given the pilot nature of this proposed study inferential statistics and reporting of statistical significance will not be used Feasibility outcomes will be descriptive including calculating the percent of individuals enrolled in the study versus those eligible and the percent of individuals who remain in the study at month 1 Aims 1 and 2 will help establish intervention acceptability and feasibility The images of the patients will be stored in the encrypted laptop and analyzed at UTD Also that the videos at UTD will be destroyed after 5 years but a copy will be kept at the Dallas VA
Using weekly telephone support and online ad-hoc support features of the proposed system adverse event data will be obtained and further intervention will be initiated as needed for any safety issues that may arise during this pilot study
Aim1 Design and develop a feasible mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain in patients with lower limb amputation qualifying for on-going mirror therapy
Hypothesis 1 The investigators hypothesize that the mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain will be feasible and well received by a sample of patients with lower limb amputation needing mirror therapy
Aim2 Evaluate functional outcomes in a sample of lower limb amputees n10 using this mixed reality based system to manage phantom pain
Hypothesis 2 Using this system the investigators hypothesize that patients who participate in the mixed reality based system will show improvements in patient-reported outcome measures PROs The investigators also hypothesize that this mixed reality based system will help to alleviate the phantom pain based on Pain questionnaires and visual analog scale VAS
Patients 18 years of age and over with history of lower limb amputation and complaint of phantom limb pain Phantom limb pain is a condition experienced commonly by patients with major limb amputations
Men and women over the age of 18 with lower limb amputations greater than 3 months post surgery with phantom limb pain
-Exclusion criteria ---
Patients with lower limb amputations with open wounds or active infection in residual or contralateral limbs
Patients with history of seizures
Patients with visual self-reported or cognitive impairment assessed by the mini-mental state examination that interferes with ability to interact with participate in and adhere to a computerized rehabilitation system
Any patient with a cardiac event in the last 6 months
Any patient with an active medical issue to minimize risk of exacerbating their condition
Lives more than 60 miles away from the Dallas VA Medical Center
Any patient with the motion sickness induced by head mounted displays HMDs or immersive environment
Any patient experiencing the motion sickness induced by HMDs during the therapy session can also opt out of the study
In this exploratory pilot study a convenience sample of 10 patients will be recruited A sample of 10 subjects is adequate and consistent with other pilot behavioral intervention trials at the VA that have been completed and published
This is a pilot study is intended to yield preliminary data that will inform a fully powered trial to determine effectiveness of the novel Mixed Reality based system to manage phantom painA HIPAA waiver will be obtained to screen patients with lower limb amputation in the outpatient PMR clinics Eligible study candidates will be identified either during an initial visit as an outpatient during clinic visit with the physiatrist or review of prior visit with physiatrist The eligible pre-screened subjects will undergo a basic evaluation by rehabilitation physician After the evaluation the patient will be asked to participate in the study or sent invitation letter Once the eligible patient consents to enroll in the study with specific emphasis on safely performing the exercises independently at home The research team will provide the laptop camera and instruct the patient in its use at their home The patient will then use the system and perform the personalized home exercises every day for a 1 month period to evaluate sustainability of exercise behavior At the end of this period the system will be returned At initial clinic visit visit at week 1 and 1 month visit the patient will fill out pain questionnaires functional questionnaire without any identifiable PHI The images of the patients performing the exercises will be stored in the encrypted laptop and analyzed at UTD Also that the videos at UTD will be destroyed after 5 years but a copy will be kept at the Dallas VA
A HIPAA waiver will be obtained to screen patients with lower limb amputation in the outpatient clinics Eligible study candidates will be identified based on visit as an outpatient following hospital discharge the eligible pre-screened subjects will undergo a basic evaluation by rehabilitation physician After the evaluation the patient will be asked to participate in the study in person or by invitation letter Once the eligible patient consents to enroll in the study with specific emphasis on safely performing the exercises independently at home The research team will provide the laptop camera and instruct the patient in its use at their home The patient will then use the system and perform the personalized home exercises every day for a 1 month period to evaluate sustainability of exercise behavior At the end of this period the system will be returned by the patient at the final study visit or can be retrieved at subjects home at subjects request if unable to bring to final visit by research assistant Setting of the Study The subject will be participating in a therapy session of 15 minutes per day for a duration of 4 weeks Before starting a session the subject will be provided with oral instructions about the overall system and the purpose of study They will be asked to fill out a questionnaire asking the status of phantom pain phantom limb movement stress level etc After completing the questionnaire they will be allowed to move in virtual world to get acquainted Each session consists of three sub-sections where the subject is asked to play three different virtual games These virtual games are designed specifically for lower limb amputees Each game is targeting certain types of muscle movement We focused mainly on three types of movements 1 knee flexion and extension 2 ankle dorsiflexion and planar flexion and 3 tandem coordinated bilateral lower extremity movement Each game will be played only for 5 minutes After completing each sub-session the subject is asked to fill out similar questionnaire to record the effect
System Overview The system consists of one Microsoft Kinect camera Oculus Rift and a computer system with sufficient processing power Microsoft Kinect is used to scan the person and to create corresponding 3D model As shown in Figure 3 the 3D model for the phantom limb is obtained by mirroring the 3D model of the intact limb So the subject will be able to perceive both the limb in the virtual world The system provides a mixed reality based implementation of mirror therapy for managing phantom pain
Major features of this system include
Unconstrained movement As patient will be performing exercise in virtual environment the movement is not restricted by limited space as in case of traditional mirror box therapy where user can only move in the limits of box dimension Realistic illusion of phantom limb As the MrMAPP framework is using RGB-D camera to capture the movement of patients intact limb and mirror it to create the illusion of the phantom limb the illusion obtained is very realistic instead of using pre-built 3D model of a limb See Figure 4 Patient Encouragement Use of an immersive gaming environment motivates and keeps the patient engaging while performing exercise With the help of virtual reality various engaging game can be developed that helps to remove monotonousness in therapy sessions
Feedback with positive Reinforcement As each game is designed to encourage a patient to perform certain type of exercise the points earned in the game motivates the patient to perform better Adherence and compliance monitoring by recording and annotating the therapy sessions the coaching software will monitor parameters such as number of repetitions dates and times of exercises as well as correctness of performing the exercises This will serve as a real-time diary which is considered more reliable than self-report diaries that rely on patient recall of activityFunctional Outcome Measures a Visual Analog Scale for pain measurement VAS and b McGill Pain questionnaire c Additional questions that composite of the Mobility Activities of Daily LivingInstrumental Activities of Daily Living and Social Participation
At the end of the study the patient will have the option to leave feedback and suggestions for future use of this system
Descriptive methods will be used to characterize the sample population Pre-post t-tests or equivalent will be used to compare outcomes at one week and 1 month Given the pilot nature of this proposed study inferential statistics and reporting of statistical significance will not be used Feasibility outcomes will be descriptive including calculating the percent of individuals enrolled in the study versus those eligible and the percent of individuals who remain in the study at month 1 Aims 1 and 2 will help establish intervention acceptability and feasibility The images of the patients will be stored in the encrypted laptop and analyzed at UTD Also that the videos at UTD will be destroyed after 5 years but a copy will be kept at the Dallas VA
Using weekly telephone support and online ad-hoc support features of the proposed system adverse event data will be obtained and further intervention will be initiated as needed for any safety issues that may arise during this pilot study
Study Oversight
Has Oversight DMC:
None
Is a FDA Regulated Drug?:
False
Is a FDA Regulated Device?:
False
Is an Unapproved Device?:
None
Is a PPSD?:
None
Is a US Export?:
None
Is an FDA AA801 Violation?:
None