Ignite Creation Date:
2024-05-06 @ 1:25 AM
Last Modification Date:
2024-10-26 @ 11:04 AM
Study NCT ID:
NCT01808755
Status:
COMPLETED
Last Update Posted:
2014-05-21
First Post:
2013-03-07
Brief Title:
D Mannose in Recurrent Urinary Tract Infections
Sponsor:
Fondazione IRCCS Policlinico San Matteo di Pavia
Organization:
Fondazione IRCCS Policlinico San Matteo di Pavia
Study Overview
Official Title:
Recurrent Urinary Tract Infections in Adult Women a Pilot Study With Oral D Mannose
Status:
COMPLETED
Status Verified Date:
2014-04
Last Known Status:
None
Delayed Posting:
No
If Stopped, Why?:
Not Stopped
Has Expanded Access:
False
If Expanded Access, NCT#:
N/A
Has Expanded Access, NCT# Status:
N/A
Acronym:
None
Brief Summary:
Background- In recurrent urinary tract infections RUTIs usual prophylactic antibiotic regimes do not change the long term risk of recurrence
Objective- D-Mannose is a sugar it sticks to E coli bacteria the aim of the study was to evaluate its efficacy in the treatment and prophylaxis of recurrent UTIs
Design setting and participants- In this crossover trial female patient were eligible for the study if they had recurrent UTIs that is three ore more episodes during the preceding 12 months Suitable patients were randomly assigned to antibiotic treatment with trimethoprimsulfamethoxazole or to a regimen of oral D Mannose for 24 weeks and received the other intervention in the second phase of the study
Outcome measurements and statistical analysis- The time to recurrence of UTI bladder pain VAS p and urinary urgency VAS u were evaluated at the end of antibiotic therapy and at the and of 24 weeks fo D Mannose The results for quantitative variables were expressed as mean values and SD as they were all normally distributed Shapiro-Wilk test T-test for paired data was used to analyze differences of time of recurrence VAS pain Vas urgency and number of voidings between treatment Data analysis was performed with STATA statistical package release 111 2010 Stata Corporation College Station Texas USA
Objective- D-Mannose is a sugar it sticks to E coli bacteria the aim of the study was to evaluate its efficacy in the treatment and prophylaxis of recurrent UTIs
Design setting and participants- In this crossover trial female patient were eligible for the study if they had recurrent UTIs that is three ore more episodes during the preceding 12 months Suitable patients were randomly assigned to antibiotic treatment with trimethoprimsulfamethoxazole or to a regimen of oral D Mannose for 24 weeks and received the other intervention in the second phase of the study
Outcome measurements and statistical analysis- The time to recurrence of UTI bladder pain VAS p and urinary urgency VAS u were evaluated at the end of antibiotic therapy and at the and of 24 weeks fo D Mannose The results for quantitative variables were expressed as mean values and SD as they were all normally distributed Shapiro-Wilk test T-test for paired data was used to analyze differences of time of recurrence VAS pain Vas urgency and number of voidings between treatment Data analysis was performed with STATA statistical package release 111 2010 Stata Corporation College Station Texas USA
Detailed Description:
INTRODUCTION Urinary tract infections UTIs are among the most common infectious diseases with a substantial financial burden to society In Europe data on the presence of various types of UTIs indicate a high impact on quality of life of people affected it is important the impact of urinary tract infections on the economy in general and on the health system in particular In the US urinary tract infections account for more than 7 million doctor visits each year including more than 2 million visits for cystitis The bacterium E coli which is the source of 90 of urinary tract infections shows an incredible ability to survive in the human body and is able to change rapidly to survive antibiotics An infection of the urinary tract must be stopped before it begins to migrate to the kidneys where it can cause serious infections Women with frequent reinfections have a rate of 013 to 022 UTIs per month 16 to 26 infections per year For premenopausal healthy and active females recurrent UTIs are a major healthcare concern Recurrent urinary tract infection RUTI is defined as three episodes of urinary tract infection UTI with 3 positive urine cultures in the previous 12 months or two episodes in the last six months The usual present strategies employing a prophylactic antibiotic regime to prevent recurrent UTIs include long-term low-dose prophylactic antimicrobial treatment or postcoital antibiotic treatment However it seems that these strategies do not alter the long-term risk of recurrence Patients with frequent UTIs who take prophylactic antimicrobial agents for extended periods decrease their infections during prophylaxis but the rate of infection returns to pre-treatment rates when prophylaxis is stopped Long-term antibiotics do not appear to positively affect the patients basic susceptibility to infections The cell wall of E coli bacteria has tiny finger-like projections that contain complex molecules called lectins on their surface These lectins act as a cellular glue that binds the bacteria to the bladder wall so they cannot be easily rinsed out by urination In this pilot study the aim was to evaluate if oral D Mannose could be used as a safe and effective treatment and as a prophylactic measure for recurrent UTIs in adult women
PATIENTS AND METHODS Suitable female patients with recurrent urinary tract infections who were visited at the outpatient Clinic of our Urology Department were eligible for study The work has been conducted in accordance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki of World Medical Association Patients were enrolled in the study after treatment for the most recent urinary tract infection if they had positive urinary cultures at that time
Each participant entering the trial was assigned to one of the following treatments in a random sequence
1 A regimen of five-day antibiotic therapy with trimethoprimsulfamethoxazole 160 mg800 mg twice a day Then 1 week of antibiotic every 4 weeks for the following 23 weeks
2 A regimen of oral D Mannose 1 gr 3 times a day every 8 hours for 2 weeks and subsequently 1 gr twice a day for 22 weeks D-Mannose has the best activity when urine has neutral pH therefore patients were instructed to measure urinary pH using dipsticks and use oral sodium bicarbonate 250 mg bidor potassium citrate 1 gr bid as alkalinizing agents if pH was 7
Patients were randomly assigned to antibiotic treatment with trimethoprimsulfamethoxazole or to a regimen of oral D Mannose for 24 weeks and received the other intervention in the second phase of the study
VAS score for bladder pain VASp and for urgency VASu was evaluated before starting D Mannose and at 24 weeks The 24 hour number of voidings was obtained filling a voiding diary before and at the end of treatment with D Mannose Cure was defined as the resolution of symptoms and no post-treatment bacteriuria at the 24 week follow-up visit Cure with recurrence was defined as having resolution of symptoms with negative cultures at 12 week followed by significant UTI with bacteriuria before 24 weeks Failure was defined as having persistent symptoms and significant bacteriuria before 24 weeks The cure rate was determined for patients who met infection criteria returned for the follow-up visits and had been treated with an antimicrobial for recurrent urinary tract infection occurring twice or more times during the 6 months preceding the 24 weeks course of daily oral D Mannose The time to recurrence of UTI VAS pain and VAS urgency were evaluated at the end of antibiotic therapy and at the end of 24 week treatment with oral D Mannose Statistical Analysis- The results for quantitative variables were expressed as mean values and SD as they were all normally distributed Shapiro-Wilk test T-test for paired data was used to analyze differences of time of recurrence VAS pain Vas urgency and number of voidings between treatment Data analysis was performed with STATA statistical package release 111 2010 Stata Corporation College Station Texas USA
DISCUSSION- The approach in the management of recurrent urinary tract infections is usually to treat adequately an episode of infection and after the completion should document complete eradication with a urine culture if infection reoccurs or persists then imaging is required In the management of recurrent UTIs in women it is a common practice to fight the resistance of the bacterium E coli by varying the type of antibiotics or increasing the dose and duration of therapy However in doing so the bacteria become even more resistant to broad spectrum antibiotics Moreover the resistance of the bacterium would not increase if the infection was due to a new E coli contamination of the faeces or to sexual contact What actually appears to occur is the survival of a part of the old colony of bacteria in the urinary tract they remain latent and are reactivated by various favourable conditions the relentless recurrences are therefore not considered as reinfection It could be learnt a lot from patients and from research done on the causes of repeated urinary tract infections especially due to the bacterium E coli Uropathogenic Escherichia coli UPEC strains may contain virulence factors that allow the bacteria to penetrate into the transitional cells and form quiescent intracellular reservoirs QIRs Establishment of QIRs throughout the underlying transitional epithelium may predispose an individual to an increased likelihood of recurrence and may account for some of the frequent same-strain recurrences that are seen clinically despite appropriate antibiotic therapy A difficult aspect of treating urinary tract infections in women is the high likelihood of recurrence In a series of trials a group of susceptible women averaged 26 infections per patient per year despite the apparent effectiveness of short-term therapy While long-term prophylaxis was relatively effective in that series resistance to trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole by urinary pathogens increased to 19 in a 5-year period Although there is debate regarding the duration of antibiotic therapy emergence of drug-resistant organisms has to be considered with prolonged antibiotic use even in healthy women with uncomplicated UTIs A number of triggers lead to the reactivation of dormant Ecoli already in the bladder or the release of Ecoli pods from behind biofilms in the bladder When a first UTI is caused by E coli the risk of a second infection within 6 months is greater than when a first infection is cause by another uropathogen Although E coli was the most frequently isolated microorganism in our group of patients the limited number of patients studied could not confirm this assumption The chemical structure of D-Mannose causes it to stick to E coli bacteria maybe even more tenaciously than E coli adheres to human cells Although the mechanism of how it works is complicated theoretically if enough D-mannose is present in the urine it binds to the bacteria and prevents them from attaching to the urinary tract lining Our clinical experience shows that D Mannose represents a useful choice to address the problem of recurrent UTIs The time required to develop a new infection or for the re-emergence of the bacterial reservoir as can be assumed from new data is significantly longer with a prolonged course of oral D Mannose than with antibiotic treatment even when these are used for long periods at a low dose or in cycles We actually know mannose has no bactericidal properties and it might well be that the dosage and duration of therapy have to be individualized according to bacterial growth and replication speed in the bladder and urinary tract The major part of mannose ingested is eliminated with urine and works by binding to bacteria concentrated in infected urine and attempting to perpetuate infection by binding to mannose receptors of urothelial bladder cells this mechanism being the one involved in most cases of recurrences In most cases recurrences are wrongly regarded as re-infections it is highly likely that bactericidal molecules not possessing the same properties cannot produce the same consistent effect that is the elimination of more and more loads of bacteria with urine alive albeit inactivated motionless devoid of pathogenic potential due to mannose linked to them
PATIENTS AND METHODS Suitable female patients with recurrent urinary tract infections who were visited at the outpatient Clinic of our Urology Department were eligible for study The work has been conducted in accordance with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki of World Medical Association Patients were enrolled in the study after treatment for the most recent urinary tract infection if they had positive urinary cultures at that time
Each participant entering the trial was assigned to one of the following treatments in a random sequence
1 A regimen of five-day antibiotic therapy with trimethoprimsulfamethoxazole 160 mg800 mg twice a day Then 1 week of antibiotic every 4 weeks for the following 23 weeks
2 A regimen of oral D Mannose 1 gr 3 times a day every 8 hours for 2 weeks and subsequently 1 gr twice a day for 22 weeks D-Mannose has the best activity when urine has neutral pH therefore patients were instructed to measure urinary pH using dipsticks and use oral sodium bicarbonate 250 mg bidor potassium citrate 1 gr bid as alkalinizing agents if pH was 7
Patients were randomly assigned to antibiotic treatment with trimethoprimsulfamethoxazole or to a regimen of oral D Mannose for 24 weeks and received the other intervention in the second phase of the study
VAS score for bladder pain VASp and for urgency VASu was evaluated before starting D Mannose and at 24 weeks The 24 hour number of voidings was obtained filling a voiding diary before and at the end of treatment with D Mannose Cure was defined as the resolution of symptoms and no post-treatment bacteriuria at the 24 week follow-up visit Cure with recurrence was defined as having resolution of symptoms with negative cultures at 12 week followed by significant UTI with bacteriuria before 24 weeks Failure was defined as having persistent symptoms and significant bacteriuria before 24 weeks The cure rate was determined for patients who met infection criteria returned for the follow-up visits and had been treated with an antimicrobial for recurrent urinary tract infection occurring twice or more times during the 6 months preceding the 24 weeks course of daily oral D Mannose The time to recurrence of UTI VAS pain and VAS urgency were evaluated at the end of antibiotic therapy and at the end of 24 week treatment with oral D Mannose Statistical Analysis- The results for quantitative variables were expressed as mean values and SD as they were all normally distributed Shapiro-Wilk test T-test for paired data was used to analyze differences of time of recurrence VAS pain Vas urgency and number of voidings between treatment Data analysis was performed with STATA statistical package release 111 2010 Stata Corporation College Station Texas USA
DISCUSSION- The approach in the management of recurrent urinary tract infections is usually to treat adequately an episode of infection and after the completion should document complete eradication with a urine culture if infection reoccurs or persists then imaging is required In the management of recurrent UTIs in women it is a common practice to fight the resistance of the bacterium E coli by varying the type of antibiotics or increasing the dose and duration of therapy However in doing so the bacteria become even more resistant to broad spectrum antibiotics Moreover the resistance of the bacterium would not increase if the infection was due to a new E coli contamination of the faeces or to sexual contact What actually appears to occur is the survival of a part of the old colony of bacteria in the urinary tract they remain latent and are reactivated by various favourable conditions the relentless recurrences are therefore not considered as reinfection It could be learnt a lot from patients and from research done on the causes of repeated urinary tract infections especially due to the bacterium E coli Uropathogenic Escherichia coli UPEC strains may contain virulence factors that allow the bacteria to penetrate into the transitional cells and form quiescent intracellular reservoirs QIRs Establishment of QIRs throughout the underlying transitional epithelium may predispose an individual to an increased likelihood of recurrence and may account for some of the frequent same-strain recurrences that are seen clinically despite appropriate antibiotic therapy A difficult aspect of treating urinary tract infections in women is the high likelihood of recurrence In a series of trials a group of susceptible women averaged 26 infections per patient per year despite the apparent effectiveness of short-term therapy While long-term prophylaxis was relatively effective in that series resistance to trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole by urinary pathogens increased to 19 in a 5-year period Although there is debate regarding the duration of antibiotic therapy emergence of drug-resistant organisms has to be considered with prolonged antibiotic use even in healthy women with uncomplicated UTIs A number of triggers lead to the reactivation of dormant Ecoli already in the bladder or the release of Ecoli pods from behind biofilms in the bladder When a first UTI is caused by E coli the risk of a second infection within 6 months is greater than when a first infection is cause by another uropathogen Although E coli was the most frequently isolated microorganism in our group of patients the limited number of patients studied could not confirm this assumption The chemical structure of D-Mannose causes it to stick to E coli bacteria maybe even more tenaciously than E coli adheres to human cells Although the mechanism of how it works is complicated theoretically if enough D-mannose is present in the urine it binds to the bacteria and prevents them from attaching to the urinary tract lining Our clinical experience shows that D Mannose represents a useful choice to address the problem of recurrent UTIs The time required to develop a new infection or for the re-emergence of the bacterial reservoir as can be assumed from new data is significantly longer with a prolonged course of oral D Mannose than with antibiotic treatment even when these are used for long periods at a low dose or in cycles We actually know mannose has no bactericidal properties and it might well be that the dosage and duration of therapy have to be individualized according to bacterial growth and replication speed in the bladder and urinary tract The major part of mannose ingested is eliminated with urine and works by binding to bacteria concentrated in infected urine and attempting to perpetuate infection by binding to mannose receptors of urothelial bladder cells this mechanism being the one involved in most cases of recurrences In most cases recurrences are wrongly regarded as re-infections it is highly likely that bactericidal molecules not possessing the same properties cannot produce the same consistent effect that is the elimination of more and more loads of bacteria with urine alive albeit inactivated motionless devoid of pathogenic potential due to mannose linked to them
Study Oversight
Has Oversight DMC:
None
Is a FDA Regulated Drug?:
None
Is a FDA Regulated Device?:
None
Is an Unapproved Device?:
None
Is a PPSD?:
None
Is a US Export?:
None
Is an FDA AA801 Violation?:
None